Rebuild with forged internals vs. rebuild with stock internals?
#1
Rebuild with forged internals vs. rebuild with stock internals?
hello, I am new to this forum and this is my first post. I have a 2003 Mustang GT. It has 170,000 miles and is burning oil and smokes a good bit from the exhaust pipes under acceleration. From what I've heard I think it's my rings that are bad. (If that is incorrect please inform me as I am not sure about that). I want to supercharge my car but obviously that isn't a good idea now since my motor is in need of a rebuild. My question is what steps should I take with the car to eventually have it supercharged. Money is an issue so I would like to know my most affordable options. Should I rebuild it back to stock specs, rebuild with forged internals, find a used 4.6 to drop in? I only plan to run around 350 to 400 rwhp so I don't know if I should forge it or not. It is a daily driver as of now so obviously reliability is a big thing. Thank you in advance for any advice!
#2
If you don't plan on going past 400rw then a stock rebuild would be sufficient.
However, this is a golden opportunity to do something a little better than stock. If possible to keep driving it as is for a bit while you put together $$ for forged components, that's what most would probably try to do.
However, this is a golden opportunity to do something a little better than stock. If possible to keep driving it as is for a bit while you put together $$ for forged components, that's what most would probably try to do.
#3
If you don't plan on going past 400rw then a stock rebuild would be sufficient.
However, this is a golden opportunity to do something a little better than stock. If possible to keep driving it as is for a bit while you put together $$ for forged components, that's what most would probably try to do.
However, this is a golden opportunity to do something a little better than stock. If possible to keep driving it as is for a bit while you put together $$ for forged components, that's what most would probably try to do.
#4
https://mustangforums.com/forum/4-6l...e-rebuild.html
Sent from my XT1080 using IB AutoGroup
Last edited by VTX1800N1; 11-13-2014 at 08:01 AM.
#5
hello, I am new to this forum and this is my first post. I have a 2003 Mustang GT. It has 170,000 miles and is burning oil and smokes a good bit from the exhaust pipes under acceleration. From what I've heard I think it's my rings that are bad. (If that is incorrect please inform me as I am not sure about that). I want to supercharge my car but obviously that isn't a good idea now since my motor is in need of a rebuild. My question is what steps should I take with the car to eventually have it supercharged. Money is an issue so I would like to know my most affordable options. Should I rebuild it back to stock specs, rebuild with forged internals, find a used 4.6 to drop in? I only plan to run around 350 to 400 rwhp so I don't know if I should forge it or not. It is a daily driver as of now so obviously reliability is a big thing. Thank you in advance for any advice!
#6
This is a no brainier. If you plan on Supercharging your car and looking to go 350 or so to the wheels FORGE IT. I did the mistake of putting a SC on my car and not forge it and kaboom. I only put 389 to the rear wheels back then. Also I can promise you that your rwhp goals will go up and you will want more. As stated above, it will be kinda expensive (forging it) but it will most defiently pay off in the end.
Last edited by VTX1800N1; 11-14-2014 at 08:05 AM.
#7
Today I went to a local shop that sells engine parts and got a couple quotes for rebuild kits. The first one I got was a complete kit with Sealed Power forged pistons and Eagle forged h beam rods, the total for just parts was $1,831. I also got a quote for just a stock rebuild without the forged pistons and rods and the total was $1,423. How do these parts sound quality and price wise? I figure that I might as well spend an extra 400 bucks on the forged components. Please let me know what you think.
#9
The guy at the engine place also said that having forged pistons and rods on a daily driver is a pain because the pistons expand when they get hot and you have to let the car warm up before you drive it and let it cool down before you restart it. He also mentioned that was because there was less silicone in them. I had never heard of this but he seemed to know what he was talking about.
#10
The guy at the engine place also said that having forged pistons and rods on a daily driver is a pain because the pistons expand when they get hot and you have to let the car warm up before you drive it and let it cool down before you restart it. He also mentioned that was because there was less silicone in them. I had never heard of this but he seemed to know what he was talking about.
A forged piston has much lower silicon content and a much more even grain structure because of the forging process. This makes it much stronger. The trade off is that the low silicon content means greater thermal expansion. Thus, the piston to wall clearance must be greater, especially when cold. This results in some piston noise on cold start and you should not drive the engine hard until it reaches operating temperature. However, that doesn't mean you can't drive it at all until it warms up. I've also never heard of the requirement to wait till a warm forged engine cools before restarting it.
The scuff resistance is also less, so the pistons will not last as long, although coatings can mitigate this.
However, forged pistons do not shatter like hypereutectic pistons under detonation. Their ring lands are also much stronger, thus forged pistons can handle much higher power levels.
Sent from my XT1080 using IB AutoGroup
Last edited by VTX1800N1; 11-14-2014 at 01:40 PM.