Newbie engine builder - Refreshing a stock short block (machine work?)
#11
RE: Newbie engine builder - Refreshing a stock short block (machine work?)
ORIGINAL: my77stang
your missing the point of the whole deal. the ONLY part of the motor that was ever "stronger" than other years were they pistons themselves in the late 80's. you will be boring your block, which means even if you HAVE the forged stock pistons they will find their new home in the trash can.
so, do you replace a forged piston with a inferior piston - and then add a blower? or do you replace it with an equally strong (or stronger) product?
your missing the point of the whole deal. the ONLY part of the motor that was ever "stronger" than other years were they pistons themselves in the late 80's. you will be boring your block, which means even if you HAVE the forged stock pistons they will find their new home in the trash can.
so, do you replace a forged piston with a inferior piston - and then add a blower? or do you replace it with an equally strong (or stronger) product?
Oh, and why is this. Look here:
http://store.summitracing.com/Compar...FEM-MHP174-321
The non-forged piston engine rebuild kit has a compression ratio of 9.08:1, and the equivalent forged set has a ratio of 10.13:1. All the forged piston sets have this ratio. Why? I don't want to be increasing my compression ratio if I'm going forced induction.
#12
RE: Newbie engine builder - Refreshing a stock short block (machine work?)
man..its just not completely clicking for you...hes saying it wouldnt matter if your pistons are plastic in there now...when you bore it to a 306..those pistons will be just a pile in the driveway...youll have to get new pistons so it doesnt matter what you have in there now..and ur link didnt work..but are u sure the ones ur looking at arnt domed?...and yes the foxes up till 92 had forged pistons just so ya know...in 93 they started the hyper pistons..
#13
RE: Newbie engine builder - Refreshing a stock short block (machine work?)
ok for his sake and my own do you guys have a ball park estimate of what it would cost for a machine shop to bore .030 over, polish the crank, balance it, and clean up the block?
i kno all machine shops are diffreent but i have absolutly no idea. and also when you send the machine shop the pistons/crank/block will they assemble it too or no? and should it be taken apart first? or just go in as a stripped shortblock?
not to hyjack the thread but i think the OP might want to kno this aswell.
i kno all machine shops are diffreent but i have absolutly no idea. and also when you send the machine shop the pistons/crank/block will they assemble it too or no? and should it be taken apart first? or just go in as a stripped shortblock?
not to hyjack the thread but i think the OP might want to kno this aswell.
#14
RE: Newbie engine builder - Refreshing a stock short block (machine work?)
everything should br broken down when you drop your stuff off for machining.
let them clean, magnaflux, knock in new cam bearings, bore and deck the block, grind the crank, recon the rods with arp bolts, and do the heads (a valve job and resurface unless your buying new heads)
corners, compression ratios are based on the design of the piston. there are dished, flat tops, and domes. a dish will have the lowest, and a dome will have the highest. stock pistons have small dishes, and the crappy kit you were looking at was basically a stock replacement.
another thing. the motors 92 and down had the forged pistons BUT also anything older than what like 87?!?!?! had hyper or even cast pistons (cast is worst). but AGAIN that means nothing because you'll be getting new pistons.
to be perfectly honest with you, if you are having this hard of a time wrapping your head around what we're talking about now you shouldn't be building a forced induction motor. i'll almost promise you your going to be throwing this money down the drain. really, you should be starting with a basic build - and before you do that you need to spend some time reading a how-to book or at least watch a few episodes of horsepower tv LOL
let them clean, magnaflux, knock in new cam bearings, bore and deck the block, grind the crank, recon the rods with arp bolts, and do the heads (a valve job and resurface unless your buying new heads)
corners, compression ratios are based on the design of the piston. there are dished, flat tops, and domes. a dish will have the lowest, and a dome will have the highest. stock pistons have small dishes, and the crappy kit you were looking at was basically a stock replacement.
another thing. the motors 92 and down had the forged pistons BUT also anything older than what like 87?!?!?! had hyper or even cast pistons (cast is worst). but AGAIN that means nothing because you'll be getting new pistons.
to be perfectly honest with you, if you are having this hard of a time wrapping your head around what we're talking about now you shouldn't be building a forced induction motor. i'll almost promise you your going to be throwing this money down the drain. really, you should be starting with a basic build - and before you do that you need to spend some time reading a how-to book or at least watch a few episodes of horsepower tv LOL
#16
RE: Newbie engine builder - Refreshing a stock short block (machine work?)
The kind where you select all the parts yourself. Get all the best Fel Pro gaskets, especially the 1 piecers(oil pan, valve cover etc). Cometic makes good head gaskets if you want to use those instead of Fel Pro. Melling oil pumps are pretty standard for the most part, I prefer high volume myself, others high pressure,but that's a whole OTHER issue. Get a good oil pump drive shaft, either the hardened that comes with some of the Melling pumps, or an ARP. Pistons and rings should really be determined by what you want to do with the application. Good bearings, like Clevite or King etc. Durabond makes good cam bearings. Also get moly lube for assembly, I use it on all the internal connecting hardware so the threads are lubed. And better head/rod bolts etc, ARPs. No sense in building an engine and skimping on $50 worth of bolts only to have a head gasket blow or a rod come off the crank*shudder*.
#18
RE: Newbie engine builder - Refreshing a stock short block (machine work?)
ORIGINAL: 94Yellow50
man..its just not completely clicking for you...hes saying it wouldnt matter if your pistons are plastic in there now...when you bore it to a 306..those pistons will be just a pile in the driveway...youll have to get new pistons so it doesnt matter what you have in there now..and ur link didnt work..but are u sure the ones ur looking at arnt domed?...and yes the foxes up till 92 had forged pistons just so ya know...in 93 they started the hyper pistons..
man..its just not completely clicking for you...hes saying it wouldnt matter if your pistons are plastic in there now...when you bore it to a 306..those pistons will be just a pile in the driveway...youll have to get new pistons so it doesnt matter what you have in there now..and ur link didnt work..but are u sure the ones ur looking at arnt domed?...and yes the foxes up till 92 had forged pistons just so ya know...in 93 they started the hyper pistons..
Here, I'll try this. On a strengthscale of 1-10, if the stock block is a 6, and the stock pistons are an 8, why would you put in forged pistons with a strength of 9, when the engine's weakest link (the block)remains an unchanged6?
However, thank you for pointing out that the 92's and below had forged internals. I did not know that.
#19
RE: Newbie engine builder - Refreshing a stock short block (machine work?)
ORIGINAL: my77stang
everything should br broken down when you drop your stuff off for machining.
let them clean, magnaflux, knock in new cam bearings, bore and deck the block, grind the crank, recon the rods with arp bolts, and do the heads (a valve job and resurface unless your buying new heads)
corners, compression ratios are based on the design of the piston. there are dished, flat tops, and domes. a dish will have the lowest, and a dome will have the highest. stock pistons have small dishes, and the crappy kit you were looking at was basically a stock replacement.
another thing. the motors 92 and down had the forged pistons BUT also anything older than what like 87?!?!?! had hyper or even cast pistons (cast is worst). but AGAIN that means nothing because you'll be getting new pistons.
to be perfectly honest with you, if you are having this hard of a time wrapping your head around what we're talking about now you shouldn't be building a forced induction motor. i'll almost promise you your going to be throwing this money down the drain. really, you should be starting with a basic build - and before you do that you need to spend some time reading a how-to book or at least watch a few episodes of horsepower tv LOL
everything should br broken down when you drop your stuff off for machining.
let them clean, magnaflux, knock in new cam bearings, bore and deck the block, grind the crank, recon the rods with arp bolts, and do the heads (a valve job and resurface unless your buying new heads)
corners, compression ratios are based on the design of the piston. there are dished, flat tops, and domes. a dish will have the lowest, and a dome will have the highest. stock pistons have small dishes, and the crappy kit you were looking at was basically a stock replacement.
another thing. the motors 92 and down had the forged pistons BUT also anything older than what like 87?!?!?! had hyper or even cast pistons (cast is worst). but AGAIN that means nothing because you'll be getting new pistons.
to be perfectly honest with you, if you are having this hard of a time wrapping your head around what we're talking about now you shouldn't be building a forced induction motor. i'll almost promise you your going to be throwing this money down the drain. really, you should be starting with a basic build - and before you do that you need to spend some time reading a how-to book or at least watch a few episodes of horsepower tv LOL
I understand the shape of the piston is directly related to the compressons ratio (all about the volume). But, those kits were supposedly identical, except one had forged pistons. They both list the piston style as "flat".
Here's another link:
Forged: http://store.summitracing.com/partde...p;autoview=sku
Cast: http://store.summitracing.com/partde...p;autoview=sku
I know you have been building engines for awhile, but I'm sure you started somewhere. I had a few questions, like anyone starting would, so I didn't appreciate the jab at my intellect. I said in my first post, that I know I would probably be better off buying a block already built, but I said that I WANT to learn and do it myself. And no, I won't be throwing my money away, because I'll be asking questions (here, and I have some friends that have build a few), even as stupid as they may seam to you, to make sure that if I don't understand something completely, I'll get all the information so I can do it right. I'm not just going to bolt this thing up blindly (which I can do right now without any help). As youknow, any monkey can bolt an engine together, but todo it right, there are a bunch of fine details that I'm trying to learn. I'm sure there was a time in your life when you built your first engine and you asked a bunch of stupid questions as well. So, thanks for the help so far, but please keep your pessimistic comments to a minimum. I'm going to continue to ask basic questions, possibly "annoying" to the expert builders, until I get it done right, and I'll be smarter for having gone through the trouble.
BTW, are there any books or DVD's you'd recommend that go through an engine rebuild? I helped 2 other friends, one of who had built engines before, build up a Chevy 350, but the guy who knew what he was doing already had the machine work and all the pieces bought and layed out before I got involved, which is why I'm asking about all the machine and prep work.
I really do appreciate the help so far. If you think my questions are stupid now, just wait until I actually start the build.
#20
RE: Newbie engine builder - Refreshing a stock short block (machine work?)
hey man i wasnt tryin to burn ya or anything...an i checked those two links n went back n forth page to page..and ur right they do list every detail the same except the comp rating...as for the strength factor deal...say u bought the hyper ones n god forbid had some detenation n toasted a piston..u wouldnt have cracked the block but your piston would be toast...if you had bought the forged ones you would have had a better chance at keeping the piston because with boost forged pistons are better than hyper because of the material