What type of Oil does everyone use?
03-17-2012, 08:59 AM
#11
1st Gear Member
Join Date: Nov 2011
Location: Nevada
Posts: 88
The TBN (detergent additives) of a true synthetic that prevent occurance of everything you listed above are far more capable of performing beyond the 5,000 mile barrier.
Everything you said above is true, but 5,000 miles is not making a top tier lubricant break a sweat. Look at two of my UOAs below. Both lubricants had over 4,000 miles on them at the second sampling. Notice how high the TBN still is. Both lubricants had a TBN of 11-12 in the virgin unused condition. 1.0 or lower is considered too low, and must be changed. These samples are in a 680 rwhp GT500, and will be much harder on oil than a 360 rwhp Coyote or 300 rwhp 4.6L N/A engine.
In this sample, 10W-30 was sampled through the dip stick tube, and is still in my engine today. Total miles on the second sample was 4,389 miles (2130 + 2259 miles). TBN content is still strong, as it's not a linear reduction process.
In this sample, 20W-50 was the first sample, then dumped. 10W-40 was the second and third sample taken through the dip stick tube. 10W-40 was dumped after the third sample. Total miles on the third sample was 4,124 miles (2033 + 2091 miles). Sample was wasted in order to move on and test 10W-30, not changed because it was required to do so.
Everything you said above is true, but 5,000 miles is not making a top tier lubricant break a sweat. Look at two of my UOAs below. Both lubricants had over 4,000 miles on them at the second sampling. Notice how high the TBN still is. Both lubricants had a TBN of 11-12 in the virgin unused condition. 1.0 or lower is considered too low, and must be changed. These samples are in a 680 rwhp GT500, and will be much harder on oil than a 360 rwhp Coyote or 300 rwhp 4.6L N/A engine.
In this sample, 10W-30 was sampled through the dip stick tube, and is still in my engine today. Total miles on the second sample was 4,389 miles (2130 + 2259 miles). TBN content is still strong, as it's not a linear reduction process.
In this sample, 20W-50 was the first sample, then dumped. 10W-40 was the second and third sample taken through the dip stick tube. 10W-40 was dumped after the third sample. Total miles on the third sample was 4,124 miles (2033 + 2091 miles). Sample was wasted in order to move on and test 10W-30, not changed because it was required to do so.
However while TBN represents is the acid neutralizing capacity of engine oil, it does not magically remove or counter the long term effects of potentially abrasive insolubles or the solvent like effects even a normal amount of fuel dilution has on any type of lubricant.
I sleep better at night knowing those contaminants are being removed from my engines on a more frequent basis rather than just assuming the effects of those contaminants are being countered by the additive package in my engine oil.
There is also a definite benefit to putting the car on the rack on a more frequent basis and giving the whole car a look over to catch any other potential problems before they manifest themselves down the road.
You certainly have a wealth of knowledge on the subject, but I still must respectfully disagree.
03-17-2012, 11:58 AM
#12
4th Gear Member
Join Date: Feb 2008
Location: Pensacola, Florida
Posts: 1,465
Amsoil does have very strong TBN numbers, nobody can deny that.
However while TBN represents is the acid neutralizing capacity of engine oil, it does not magically remove or counter the long term effects of potentially abrasive insolubles or the solvent like effects even a normal amount of fuel dilution has on any type of lubricant.
I sleep better at night knowing those contaminants are being removed from my engines on a more frequent basis rather than just assuming the effects of those contaminants are being countered by the additive package in my engine oil.
There is also a definite benefit to putting the car on the rack on a more frequent basis and giving the whole car a look over to catch any other potential problems before they manifest themselves down the road.
You certainly have a wealth of knowledge on the subject, but I still must respectfully disagree.
However while TBN represents is the acid neutralizing capacity of engine oil, it does not magically remove or counter the long term effects of potentially abrasive insolubles or the solvent like effects even a normal amount of fuel dilution has on any type of lubricant.
I sleep better at night knowing those contaminants are being removed from my engines on a more frequent basis rather than just assuming the effects of those contaminants are being countered by the additive package in my engine oil.
There is also a definite benefit to putting the car on the rack on a more frequent basis and giving the whole car a look over to catch any other potential problems before they manifest themselves down the road.
You certainly have a wealth of knowledge on the subject, but I still must respectfully disagree.
Using watered down Mobil 1, I agree with you 100%. It's not what it once was. Now they use "VISOM" highly refined petroleum to save money while charging the customer more, yet still calling it "Fully Synthetic".
03-18-2012, 12:24 PM
#15
4th Gear Member
Join Date: Feb 2008
Location: Pensacola, Florida
Posts: 1,465
OE is 100% group III hydrocracked highly refined petroleum
XL is a blend of group III and group IV (PAO true synthetic)
SS is 100% true synthetic
Amsoil recommends no more than 6 month intervals with OE or XL, you want to use SS for once a year oil changes.
03-26-2012, 10:00 AM
#16
2nd Gear Member
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: GA
Posts: 261
My mom's '89 Mustang had amazing service from Castrol Syntec (I know it's not a true synthetic). I was a fan of Mobile 1 but then switched to Redline and Amsoil when the local stores carried them. However, the stores quit carrying those brands and I moved on to Royal Purple. Now my loyalty follows either Royal Purple or Castrol Edge Titanium (not sure if this in a real synthetic or not) depending on which brand is having a sale at the time of purchase. Those are the ones I run in the S-10, Colorado, and my mom's '03 Mustang.
Now for my old horse I run Mobile 1 Delvac diesel oil.
Now for my old horse I run Mobile 1 Delvac diesel oil.
04-17-2012, 11:08 AM
#18
I've been meaning to try amsoil for awhile now and get a UOA done, but I keep getting lazy, and no one mentioned the number one most important factory benefiting regular oil change intervals based on time. Amsoil= 1 day down the garage a year to take your time doing and oil change and drinkins some drinks with the guys. Group III refined oils= 1 day every 3 months down the garage with the guys and some drinks AWAY FROM THE WOMENNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN.
04-17-2012, 11:40 AM
#19
4th Gear Member
Join Date: Feb 2008
Location: Pensacola, Florida
Posts: 1,465
I've been meaning to try amsoil for awhile now and get a UOA done, but I keep getting lazy, and no one mentioned the number one most important factory benefiting regular oil change intervals based on time. Amsoil= 1 day down the garage a year to take your time doing and oil change and drinkins some drinks with the guys. Group III refined oils= 1 day every 3 months down the garage with the guys and some drinks AWAY FROM THE WOMENNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN.
away from the women, haha!
04-26-2012, 08:32 AM
#20
1st Gear Member
Join Date: Jan 2012
Location: TN
Posts: 97
Anyone use SWEPCO? They make a 5w20 now. Friend of mine is a dealer, so I've been thinking of giving it a try, but not much literature out there other than their in house stuff. Apparently a lot of Porsche guys swear by it, but that's a completely different style engine than we deal with.