Go Back   MustangForums.com > Ford Mustang Tech > Saleen, Roush and Boss Mustangs
Sign in using an external account
Register Forgot Password?
Search


Saleen, Roush and Boss Mustangs Discussions on Saleen, Roush, and late model Shinoda Boss Models within. SVT models, check the 4.6L section.

Welcome to Mustang Forums!
Welcome to Mustang Forums.

You are currently viewing our forum as a guest, which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our community, at no cost, you will have access to post topics, communicate privately with other members (PM), respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is free, fast and simple, so please join our community today!


Factory Roush vs. Roush Clone--Buyer Beware?

Reply
 
 
 
 
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Old 10-29-2013, 04:01 PM   #21
Rachael427R
 
Join Date: Oct 2013
Vehicle: 2007 Ford Mustang 427R Convertible
Location: MD
Posts: 13
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by 427Roush View Post
One of the reasons some people buy Roush Mustangs is that it's a tuned car. All of the Research and Development has been done, then tested on mules to fine tune the performance of each part. What you have is a well balanced, badged and serialized high performance car.
This was misrepresented to you. I agree that you should come up with an amount of money to sue in your lawsuit case.
One of the ways to establish the value of your car is to depreciate the cost of your year/model GT and then depreciate the cost of the upgrades.
Another route to proceed is to file in small claims court case. The fear, hassle of a lawsuit may scare the Seller into a quick settlement. Once the defendant is served, perhaps a settlement can be negotiated without ever going to court.
Great points! I think small claims may be the way to go. I can only hope that being served with papers would be enough to make him wake up and settle this between ourselves.
This ad is not displayed to registered or logged-in members.
Register your free account today and become a member on Mustang Forums!
Rachael427R is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 10-29-2013, 07:57 PM   #22
Phil in OKC
 
Phil in OKC's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2013
Vehicle: 1965 Mustang 289 4V Convertible; 2007 Saleen S281 SC Coupe
Location: Oklahoma
Posts: 23
Default

You must have got a really good (below market) price on it to blind you so much that you failed to do your DD before handing over the money. If it is done well, and you did get it for a good price, you could just enjoy it and drive it and chalk it up as one of life's little lessons.
Phil in OKC is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 12-04-2013, 07:03 PM   #23
Roush_Phantom
 
Join Date: May 2012
Vehicle: 2008 BlackJack
Location: North Carolina
Posts: 15
Default

I came across this forum and your posts on freeadvice.com. I thought it wouldn't hurt to chime in.

Roush doesn't have NADA support. NADA (National Automobile Dealers Association) can act as an archive to help set price ranges for new and used vehicles. Ford Factory Mustangs (V6, GT, 5.0, Boss, GT500) and even a Mustang tuning company (Saleen) are included. Other Mustang tuners (Ronaele, Foose, Roush, etc.) are not included. Banks or your state's DMV won't acknowledge a Roush as anything other than a GT.

You made many comments on how you are afraid of losing the alleged "value" of your car 25 years down the line because your clone wouldn't be worth as much as a true Roush. In either case your car isn't going to retain what you feel it should in terms of monetary value. A Roush car is not a collector car, but they do a damned good job with all of their badges, serial numbers, fireworks, laser light shows, etc. to make you feel that it is.

Roush originally made the first consumer Roush Mustang back in 1995. The car was expensive back then. I've seen the very 1st Roush ever made go for less than $10k on eBay a few months back. Its been nearly 20 years since that car was made now. Unfortunately, nobody cares about a tuner car without NADA support. Roush vehicles since then are victim to the same depreciation.

What does this mean for you? The car that originally had an MSRP from Roush for $50-$60k has little to no comparison for pricing when it comes time to sell. Besides the punch in the gut you get from driving a Roush vehicle off the lot in lost "value" you get an additional kick to the groin. It doesn't matter if it is new or used. I know quite a few guys that have owned Stage 3s, 427Rs, or other Roush cars and have lost 50%+ in "investment" within the first year or two. That is severe depreciation. Typically, for a Roush car you see GT trade in value plus 10-20% and that's about it regardless of if its the real deal or a clone. Roush dealers usually give you a better price however.

Buying a new Roush means losing your shirt in terms of "value." Buying a used Roush means losing less money. I've heard the same story over and over and over and over again from guys that either bought their car new or used. No one knows how to price these things, so you are the one that loses. If you buy a Roush and ever hope to recover most or all of what you have into it you better pray that the potential buyer really really loves your car.

You are going to have a hell of a time proving to a court that you lost out on a certain dollar amount, since the price tag for a used Roush is all across the board. It is not admissible in court to use an auction or a handful of private sale prices of other Roush cars to compare the alleged lost "value" versus what you actually paid. You would need an NADA value, which you can't get. You could try to get a dealership appraisal, yet you are at their mercy in this case. Sadly, you have very little to go on to prove "value." Hopefully, if you do go to court the judge won't be apathetic, but proving you were duped is going to be hard when you didn't do your homework proving the car was what seller said it was.

Per your freeadvice.com conversation you mentioned how a regular GT would be a little below $20k in price versus the one you bought. I can tell you that you couldn't take a regular GT for the price you quoted it at and build the Roush clone you did buy for what you paid. That tid-bit is the good news. The silver lining is you bought the same car you wanted to get and didn't pay the $5k or so to get the "real deal" that, in another couple of years, won't hold its value anyway.

I know this isn't the greatest of news, but as a Roush owner this is the reality you've got. You buy the car because you like it and that's about it. How do I know? Well, I too bought a used Roush (that was real) and did my homework to find this reality. Thankfully, I paid a low price on it, so the depreciation hit won't hit me as hard. I bought the car because I like it.

If you can get some money back great, but I think this is a whoops that you'll have to learn from. At the end of the day if your 427 clone is a perfect clone sans "official" Roush treatment (that its registered on their excel spreadsheet) with all of the original parts a real 427R was supposed to have you got a killer deal what you did buy. It really sucks that the guy lied to you. I'm not justifying what the douche did, but at least you can salvage something out of this. Hopefully, you can still enjoy what you have.

Last edited by Roush_Phantom; 12-04-2013 at 08:24 PM.
Roush_Phantom is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 12-08-2013, 01:39 PM   #24
LilRoush
6th Gear Member
 
LilRoush's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2007
Vehicle: Roush
Location: South FL
Posts: 8,528
Send a message via AIM to LilRoush
Default

Actually a Roush car is well known in the industry and is a collector car. The rarest early gen cars trade hands for $20K or more. The S3 (blue one I assume you are refering to didn't sell for only $10K last time Miller listed it on ebay several months ago). In fact that same car was listed for $40K by Stage 3 Motorsports in CA several years ago when I was looking at buying an early Roush to go with my 2000 S1. I ended up with my '98 instead. Early Roush SN95 cars still sell for high teens or low twenty figures for S2 or S2 plus cars. That's triple (or more) what other basic GT cars of the same year are selling for. NADA doesn't mean crap in today's world of internet. No book does. Current market value is easy to find and keep track of. That book and others like it are relics that need to be tossed out.


You sound more like an upset owner rather than someone familiar with Roush history and what the cars are worth.
__________________
~Matt
1998 Roush: M112'd Aluminum block 4.6L 2V 6 speed track car
1999 SVT: Mostly stockish
1970 Mach 1: Resto-modded monster

2000 Roush #5004 - World's FIRST M112'd V6 Mustang. Sold, but not forgotten.
LilRoush is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 12-09-2013, 04:26 PM   #25
Roush_Phantom
 
Join Date: May 2012
Vehicle: 2008 BlackJack
Location: North Carolina
Posts: 15
Default

How do I sound like an upset owner? If you read what I wrote you'd understand that I am anything but that. I paid less than a 1/3 of the original MSRP under two years ago on an RS3 with less than 15,000 miles. I'm thrilled friend. I bought the car I wanted for beans. The original two guys before me didn't fare well obviously.

My purchase may be on the low end of the spectrum, but what you are describing is on the completely opposite end. You can charge any sum for any item and if you find someone to buy it does that necessarily dictate value for all items in the same group? No, it doesn't. I'd have no problem taking your word on the prices you are saying in the area you are from. California is not the rest of the US, and outliers exist in every price pool. If they overpay for one car in one area versus many cheap examples everywhere else the adage "a fool and his gold are soon parted" would apply.

You cannot go to court give the judge a handful of over inflated examples and base your argument of value on that alone. This is the problem the OP has, which is vast inconsistency to prove value to rectify the difference between what she thought she was buying versus what she actually received. She needs a hard price provided by NADA or many appraisals to convince the court that there is a stark difference between what was sold versus what she thought she was being sold.

The OP will find many many more Roush owners on forums complaining about how the value of their car fell like a stone and they lost their shirts versus those that broke even or made money. That Roush you referenced barely sold for 1/4 of that 40K asking price. The SN95 and New Edge Roush cars can sell for the mid teens, but that is about it. Why do tell the SVT Cobras and GT500s sell for more today versus their Roush counterparts when the Roush cars had a higher original MSRP? No consistent Roush pricing among auto traders and sellers. No NADA.

Another thing, NADA values are what dealerships base their prices on. NADA prices aren't a book. It isn't a group dictating prices to dealerships or sellers. It is sellers reporting prices they are charging versus what they actually sell their vehicles for to one another through a computer database. I'd say that is quite relevant in today's "world of the internet" as you put it.

Last edited by Roush_Phantom; 12-09-2013 at 05:01 PM.
Roush_Phantom is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 12-13-2013, 03:30 PM   #26
LilRoush
6th Gear Member
 
LilRoush's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2007
Vehicle: Roush
Location: South FL
Posts: 8,528
Send a message via AIM to LilRoush
Default

Actually, you can go to court with a stack of printed off adds to determine market value of a rare Mustang. I've done it. I proved my point and won the case. All of the books/guidelines etc didn't hold any merit because none delt with the specific variation of the car. It is also why I have my rare cars appraised and as much paper work and as many photographs as possible to document them.

Market price for collectable cars isn't localized to states.... or even countries. Maybe it used to be, but not any more. People will travel for the right car, or have it shipped.

As for charging party determining value - the sellers control the price of Roush cars. If everyone starts asking less and less, the value drops. It's the owner's fault, nobody elses (it's a repeated topic on FNSweet). If nobody sells cheap, the people who want them will pay the premium for them. Owners of a rare object determine price, not the buyers.

In the last several years of watching, I have yet to see a 96-98 Roush sell for less than about double the average 96-98 Cobra in similar condition.
__________________
~Matt
1998 Roush: M112'd Aluminum block 4.6L 2V 6 speed track car
1999 SVT: Mostly stockish
1970 Mach 1: Resto-modded monster

2000 Roush #5004 - World's FIRST M112'd V6 Mustang. Sold, but not forgotten.

Last edited by LilRoush; 12-13-2013 at 03:32 PM.
LilRoush is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-20-2014, 03:27 PM   #27
01roush2
 
Join Date: Dec 2013
Vehicle: 1995 Mustang Cobra
Location: North Carolina
Posts: 9
Default

get a lawyer on a contingency basis. You don't pay if they don't win. I'm sure there is a good attorney where you are that will jump all over this.

Warm Regards,

John
01roush2 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-02-2014, 04:19 AM   #28
Mr. D
2nd Gear Member
 
Mr. D's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2008
Posts: 395
Default

I have read many of the posts here and I think some who have "number plated" factory Roush cars are misunderstanding the issues involved in buying a Roush because they are understandably proud of their "number plated" cars. The real issue is that cars should never be misrepresented!

My understanding is as follows:

1. There are Roush cars with a "number plate" that are a modified Mustang sent from Ford to Roush and then retailed by Ford as a Roush. If you will only happy with the bragging rights of a Roush with a "number Plate" coming from the Roush factory, then do the research and make sure that's what you are getting!

2. There are Roush Mustangs that have been modifed with genuine Roush parts by an authorized Roush dealer and mechanic under Roush specifications that will not have a "number plate" and may have various combinations of Roush parts. If you are mainly interested in the performance and/or maybe look of a Roush you may be very happy with a Roush Mustang modified after the original sale by an authorized Roush Dealer and Mechanic according to Roush specifications and warrantees! Also some Ford Dealers have sent new Mustangs to Roush authorized dealers to have these modifications done prior to the original sale on the lot!

3. There are Mustangs that may only have decals, or have had non authorized or guaranteed work done by owners themselves! If you buy a Mustang that has not been assembled by a Roush authorized dealer and mechanic using Roush specifications and having a Roush warrantee you buy such a car at your own great risk! [B]

In my opinion, whether, or not you call a Mustang a Roush is determined by whether Roush controlled and warranteed the modification of the car, rather than when the modification was done. If Roush didn't not want these cars called a Roush they would not have authorized dealers installing Roush mechanical parts with a Roush guarrantee! I bought my Mustang and had it sent to a Roush authorized dealer. Others can decide if they think it is a Roush, or not, but it had a Roush guarrantee and it runs like a scalded cat! To each his own, but we all agree, "Just don't misrepresent the car!"




__________________
Maximum sig size is 250 px high X 500 px wide. Thank you.

Do you attack people who make posts you don't agree with? https://yourlogicalfallacyis.com/ad-hominem Abolish lazy terms: awesome, epic, amazing, extreme, sketchy, really?, "This bad boy", & "That's what I'm talking about!"(smile)

Last edited by Mr. D; 02-02-2014 at 04:48 AM.
Mr. D is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-02-2014, 11:36 AM   #29
LilRoush
6th Gear Member
 
LilRoush's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2007
Vehicle: Roush
Location: South FL
Posts: 8,528
Send a message via AIM to LilRoush
Default

For clarification on #2 -

Roush authorized dealer/shop builds in the earlier generations (95-04) did happen, and those cars were all serialized (in the door jam). In reality, most of the cars prior to 2001 were done by outsourced authorized builders. (IE: My 1998 Roush was built by Braco Racing in Feb of '98. My 2000 Roush was built at Roush Racing, in Mansfield, TX.)

Serial numbers where hit and miss until 1999. But simply put for anything 1999 or newer, if the car is not serialized, it's not a 'real' Roush. It's a copy/clone/owner build....what ever term someone preferes.

That being said, you can have a Roush authorized shop/dealer install Roush parts with the warrenty, but that doesn't make it a Roush car. It makes is a car with Roush parts.
__________________
~Matt
1998 Roush: M112'd Aluminum block 4.6L 2V 6 speed track car
1999 SVT: Mostly stockish
1970 Mach 1: Resto-modded monster

2000 Roush #5004 - World's FIRST M112'd V6 Mustang. Sold, but not forgotten.

Last edited by LilRoush; 02-03-2014 at 05:59 PM.
LilRoush is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-02-2014, 07:59 PM   #30
Mr. D
2nd Gear Member
 
Mr. D's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2008
Posts: 395
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by LilRoush View Post
For clarification on #2 -

That being said, you can have a Roush authorized shop/dealer install Roush parts with the warrenty, but that doesn't make it a Roush car. It makes is a car with Roush parts.
I don't mean to offend or start a big argument, but I see it a different way. First of all, "buyer beware" so you know what you are buying and don't get cheated! There is no excuse for misrepresenting a Mustang being sold. period!

If I had spent a lot of money on a Shelby, Roush, etc. with a serial number I might feel the same way, but I disagree. Some people are more about pedigrees than actual performance, or quality, etc. To me the only issue is whether, or not a car is described accurately.

Example: The car below has been examined by NCRS judges and passed as an original '61 Fuelly Corvette. It is not original, but no expert has ever been able to find anything not original! My point is.... what is the point? Unless you are misrepresenting a car in a sale and cheating someone....what is the point? A pedigree rather than anything to do with the actual car. I've seen many '61 fuelly Corvettes that were worn out rags unsafe to drive but still worth twice as much as this car because it could be documented they came from the factory as a '61 fuelly! Not my way of thinking, but everyone gets to put a value on things in their own way.



An original, or one of my disgusting fakes? LOL!



To conclude, from my point of view if Shelby, Roush, or Saleen provides a warrantee for building a Mustang by an authorized dealer then it is a Shelby, Roush, or Saleen car. It simply should not be misrepresented. In the case of some buyers, they simply do not want all the modifications that come with a "one size fits all" factory Roush or Shelby on a Ford Sales Lot, such as the suspension modifications. Many will not agree, of course, but the bottom line to me is if Roush sets up authorized Roush Dealers and mechanics to do builds with Roush warrantees on those builds than that car is a Roush! Both Mustangs of type #1, and type #2 should be respected for what they are! It appears Roush recognizes them both as Roush's! Just enjoy!



[URL=http://s523.photobucket.com/user/blackholeofspam/media/LatestEngine.png.html]



__________________
Maximum sig size is 250 px high X 500 px wide. Thank you.

Do you attack people who make posts you don't agree with? https://yourlogicalfallacyis.com/ad-hominem Abolish lazy terms: awesome, epic, amazing, extreme, sketchy, really?, "This bad boy", & "That's what I'm talking about!"(smile)

Last edited by Mr. D; 02-04-2014 at 05:01 AM.
Mr. D is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-03-2014, 06:01 PM   #31
LilRoush
6th Gear Member
 
LilRoush's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2007
Vehicle: Roush
Location: South FL
Posts: 8,528
Send a message via AIM to LilRoush
Default

The defining factor that makes it a "real" Roush is the serial number given to it by Roush when it was built. Roush will tell you the same thing - their cars have serial numbers for a reason. They also see the other cars as Mustangs with Roush parts. You can make a REALLY good copy of a Roush - but you can't fake a serial number. (Ok, you can, but you see what I'm saying.)
__________________
~Matt
1998 Roush: M112'd Aluminum block 4.6L 2V 6 speed track car
1999 SVT: Mostly stockish
1970 Mach 1: Resto-modded monster

2000 Roush #5004 - World's FIRST M112'd V6 Mustang. Sold, but not forgotten.
LilRoush is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-03-2014, 07:08 PM   #32
Mr. D
2nd Gear Member
 
Mr. D's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2008
Posts: 395
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by LilRoush View Post
The defining factor that makes it a "real" Roush is the serial number given to it by Roush when it was built. Roush will tell you the same thing - their cars have serial numbers for a reason. They also see the other cars as Mustangs with Roush parts. You can make a REALLY good copy of a Roush - but you can't fake a serial number. (Ok, you can, but you see what I'm saying.)
I agree with what you are saying in terms of my #1 type Mustang that has been converted at the Roush factory to a "number plated car". I just maintain that Roush allows the buyer to create a car with Roush performance without some of the body modifications, etc. that I as a customer did not want. I like the look of the original Mustang without body changes! I don't think it serves any real benefit for owners of Roush Factory Mustangs to make a big issue and denying that Mustangs converted by authorized Roush dealers under Roush specifications cannot be considered a Roush Mustang. I am obviously not talking about simply a Mustang with a Roush decal. (Again, no one should misrepresent a Mustang without a registered number plate as a Roush Factory car.) If my car is a Roush Clone than Roush was involved in making my clone as it provided me with a Roush warrantee good at Ford or a Roush authorized dealer for all the work and modifications done by the Roush authorized dealer.

I'm involved with a Corvette Restoration business and we see "original" early Corvettes that are dangerous junkers sitting next to concours quality clones worth a very small percentage of the "original" junker. Due to GM's lack of keeping old production records the only "real" difference that can be found is original sales paperwork which is often unavailable. Also many "real" cars are called clones/fakes because GM replaced a engine block or other numbered part before it even left the factory. We have found Corvettes that can be document as having the original block from the factory, but the numbers do not correspond correctly as GM was not concerned about matching numbers when pulling and replacing an engine.

Bottom line and my last comment! The value of a Roush factory number plated car does not have to be "defended" by demeaning or denying the obvious value of a Mustang built by an authorized Roush Dealer following Roush specifications and with a Roush guarrantee.

When I go to a car show I never say anything negative about another person's car unless I'm asked by an owner in terms of how to improve it! Everyone's car is their pride and joy, whether it has a "serial number plate" or not and it probably should be evaluated based on its quality. To each his own.... as long as you don't try to cheat someone my misrepresenting a car in a sale!
__________________
Maximum sig size is 250 px high X 500 px wide. Thank you.

Do you attack people who make posts you don't agree with? https://yourlogicalfallacyis.com/ad-hominem Abolish lazy terms: awesome, epic, amazing, extreme, sketchy, really?, "This bad boy", & "That's what I'm talking about!"(smile)

Last edited by Mr. D; 02-04-2014 at 04:55 AM.
Mr. D is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-04-2014, 03:53 PM   #33
LilRoush
6th Gear Member
 
LilRoush's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2007
Vehicle: Roush
Location: South FL
Posts: 8,528
Send a message via AIM to LilRoush
Default

If what your saying about addding parts from Roush making it a Roush, then along that same line, adding SVT Cobra wheels bought from my local SVT authorized Ford dealer now makes the car an SVT Cobra. It doesn't. It's nothing more than an owner modified car with SVT parts.
__________________
~Matt
1998 Roush: M112'd Aluminum block 4.6L 2V 6 speed track car
1999 SVT: Mostly stockish
1970 Mach 1: Resto-modded monster

2000 Roush #5004 - World's FIRST M112'd V6 Mustang. Sold, but not forgotten.
LilRoush is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-04-2014, 05:03 PM   #34
5.0GTCS
 
5.0GTCS's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2011
Vehicle: 2011 GT CS
Location: Ontario,Canada
Posts: 6
Default

1: Most attorneys offer a free 1 hr consultation ( basically, they want to evaluate weather they have a strong case or not, before proceeding).
2: A lot of merit regarding fraud is how the sale was worded AND advertised, if it clearly insinuated the car in question was indeed a Roush built and serialized car, then that becomes misleading and fraudulent advertising.

3: By default, if your lawyer wins the case, he automatically asks for legal fees to be awarded, and usually that request is granted by the presiding judge, HOWEVER you will have to secure the attorney through your own retainer...( usually and customary, first 8 hrs x hourly rate of attorney; say, $150.00/hr x 8, $1,200)

4:Locate and discuss your case with an attorney that specializes in this particular field.

5: Last but not least, there is no guarantee you would recover your money, if the seller is unemployed or in financial straits, so the more pertinent info you have to offer your attorney regarding the seller, the better your chances....find out if he owns real estate ect... best of all, good luck to you.
5.0GTCS is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-05-2014, 02:12 AM   #35
Mr. D
2nd Gear Member
 
Mr. D's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2008
Posts: 395
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by LilRoush View Post
If what your saying about addding parts from Roush making it a Roush, then along that same line, adding SVT Cobra wheels bought from my local SVT authorized Ford dealer now makes the car an SVT Cobra. It doesn't. It's nothing more than an owner modified car with SVT parts.
As you know that's not what I'm saying, nor did you give a comparable example.

Taking your Mustang to Shelby in Las Vegas and spending 20K on a build would be a better example! If you go that costly approach Shelby considers the car a Shelby even if it wasn't built that way originally. The basic difference is that Shelby sells you an expensive number plate in the process! Roush has a better approach that lets the customer decide what he wants as a final product. When I was at Shelby, it was one size fits all at about 11K or 21K, and the lesser price was all cosmetic. I wanted all performance and leave the basic Mustang body alone because I prefer the stock looks.

Anyhow, we both made our point.
__________________
Maximum sig size is 250 px high X 500 px wide. Thank you.

Do you attack people who make posts you don't agree with? https://yourlogicalfallacyis.com/ad-hominem Abolish lazy terms: awesome, epic, amazing, extreme, sketchy, really?, "This bad boy", & "That's what I'm talking about!"(smile)
Mr. D is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-05-2014, 02:23 AM   #36
Mr. D
2nd Gear Member
 
Mr. D's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2008
Posts: 395
Default

I gather the sale being discussed was a private party sale??? If it was a sale by a dealer DMV could be helpful. I was cheated by Chrysler years ago in selling me a brand new diesel truck that had be in an accident. Long story.... short, they treated me like trash until a lawyer that specialized in dealing with the auto companies told me, "You don't need me, just start a complaint against their license to sell cars with DMV!" I got three other dealers to put in writing that the "new" truck had major body and paint repairs done without disclosure, contrary to the law. Chrysler changed their tune and gave me a brand new, loaded truck! My mistake was in settling! I should have gone after "punitive" damages which might have been massive, but I didn't think that way at the time! I was trying to be reasonable! Duh!
__________________
Maximum sig size is 250 px high X 500 px wide. Thank you.

Do you attack people who make posts you don't agree with? https://yourlogicalfallacyis.com/ad-hominem Abolish lazy terms: awesome, epic, amazing, extreme, sketchy, really?, "This bad boy", & "That's what I'm talking about!"(smile)
Mr. D is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-05-2014, 06:49 PM   #37
Murgatroy
2nd Gear Member
 
Murgatroy's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2013
Vehicle: 2013 V6
Location: Kentucky
Posts: 183
Default

Mr. D, I can't help but think you are a troll. Most of your 200+ posts are you telling someone how you made a better car based on parts with no genuine prominence.

I applaud you in the fact that you have owned some nice cars.

If you want a driver, there is no shame in having a clone, but it is very arrogant to claim over and over as you do that your 'clone' was as good or better than an original.

It never will be.

It will never have the value.

While it may have the same, or better usage or availability, a clone is a clone.

I am not attacking you, I am not attacking your cars.

I am just asking that you acknowledge that most of the public will never accept a clone in the manner that they will accept an original. That is not to mean we won't appreciate it, or maybe even pay a slight premium for such, but at the end of the day, a clone is not in the same category as an original.
Murgatroy is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-05-2014, 08:34 PM   #38
LilRoush
6th Gear Member
 
LilRoush's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2007
Vehicle: Roush
Location: South FL
Posts: 8,528
Send a message via AIM to LilRoush
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Mr. D View Post
As you know that's not what I'm saying, nor did you give a comparable example.
Actually, I gave the perfect example. You said you wanted a part here and a part there of your chosing from an authorized Roush dealer and then calling the outcome a real Roush car. Doing it with Roush parts or SVT parts...it doesn't instantly make it one of those. It's simply a car with parts from a performance group.


Even if you build an exact replica of a Roush Mustang using authentic parts from Roush, put it next to a serialized car and the REAL car (with a serial number) has a higher value.

In my 10+ years of Roush ownership, I've only known one car to be made outside of Roush that was granted a serial number by Roush (It's a 2002 Stage 2 replica #5626). It used every Stage 2 part right from Roush, and it is one of the best looking Mustangs I've ever seen. That owner will be the first to tell you it's not a real Roush, but instead a Roush clone/replica.
__________________
~Matt
1998 Roush: M112'd Aluminum block 4.6L 2V 6 speed track car
1999 SVT: Mostly stockish
1970 Mach 1: Resto-modded monster

2000 Roush #5004 - World's FIRST M112'd V6 Mustang. Sold, but not forgotten.
LilRoush is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-08-2014, 05:55 AM   #39
Mr. D
2nd Gear Member
 
Mr. D's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2008
Posts: 395
Default

Murgatory,

I've noticed with some, the definition they use for a "Troll" = is a person that will not bend to their opinion and dares to have one of their own! Calling me a troll doesn't strengthen your argument! It's called an "Ad Hominem" attack! It's a comment most often made by people who simply don't like to hear opinions other than their own! You disagree with me and jumped into the conversation, but I would not call you a troll!

You said, "Even if you build an exact replica of a Roush Mustang using authentic parts from Roush, put it next to a serialized car and the REAL car (with a serial number) has a higher value."

I agree 100%!!!!....But that's not my point!


The point you and "Lil Roush" are missing, or ignoring, is that I never said that a car built by a authorized Roush dealer is the same, or worth the same as a Roush with a serial # plate! My point is that there should be a clear distinction made between a "clone" that is a fake having a couple of Roush decals and a Mustang with $10 to 20K modifications done by an authorized dealer, under Roush specfications, with a Roush warrantee. They can be done either for a Ford Dealership or an new owner. My original post tried to clarify that clear difference and was clear in stating that was not a factory made Roush, but it is still a Roush. The Ford dealer where I bought my Mustang had both Factory made, serial numbered Roush and Saleen cars and also Mustangs modified after they hit the dealership. Some were sent out to a local Roush authorized dealer and some were down by this authorized Roush Ford Dealership. They were modified under Roush specifications with a Roush guarantee related to the engine and drive train. I called Roush and they verified that such cars were considered Roush Mustangs simply constructed by an outside authorized source and were guaranteed by Roush. Obviously these Ford Dealers would be sued by Roush if they were doing something against their agreement with Roush. Ford also offered a "Ford extended warrantee" that covered the Roush modifications.

Now to be CLEAR, I am not saying that a car built by an authorized dealer is the same, or worth the same as a serial numbered factory made Roush.... but it should not be classed or valued in the same as a Mustang were Joe Blow adds a couple of decals in his garage and passes it off as a Roush! Those who own a serial numbered Roush car should not be so insecure about their car's evaluation as to need to devalue cars built by authorized Ford Dealers or independent authorized Roush dealers by saying they are not a Roush, but a clone!

People have the right to different values and opinions, BUT BELIEVE IT OR NOT there are wierdos like me that would value a supercharged Roush (at 475 to 575 H.P.) with an upgraded suspension, exhaust & brakes, etc, with far superior performance to a factory serial numbered car with simply Roush cosmetic body parts. That's why we got a Roush modifed by a Roush authorized dealer! We didn't want the Roush at the local dealer's lot, but didn't expect people to say, "That's not a Roush after we spent all that money with a Roush authorized dealer! You've hurt my feelings by calling my car a clone and I expect an apology and flowers! LOL! If you'll notice it makes no attempt to look like a Factory serial numbered Roush!

I think both types of cars should be appreciated for what they are and the word "clone" should be reserved for cars that are fake copy having nothing to do with the Roush factory or authorized dealers and Roush warrantees.


I deal with the same issue with restoring C-1 Corvettes and have people consider a early Corvette a clone because a Chevy dealer put on a piece of equipment that the car did not leave the factory with, or in a few cases we've found the block serial numbers and or transmission numbers in documented one owner cars were earlier than the build date. What if you take an original car and replace 80% of the fiberglass after an accident! Clone? We make a number of brake master cylinder safety modifications and steering modifications that are impossible to find, but make the steering much nicer because we want our customers to actually live while driving the cars! Does that make these cars clones! A friend bought a 62 Corvette with two four barrels! At the dealership another buyer hated his fuel injection unit because if idle problems! The dealer switched the 2 four barrels for the Injection & distributor and both customers were thrilled! Are both cars clones because they were built that way at the factory, although it made no real world difference! I'll leave that to you!

Again, as long as a car is described accurately, why get stuck on issues of whether it can be called a Roush or Shelby! Stop by Shelby in Las Vegas and spend $25K on your Mustang and then tell me "the only thing that makes it a Shelby is the serial number they sell you (at a high cost) with the modifications! I suppose if they put the serial number plate on with Velcrox.... then you can take it on and off and say, "Shelby... Clone! Shelby... Clone! Shelby... Clone", as you take off the serial number plate and put it back on again!

If a guy has a stock Mustang with Roush decals I agree it should not be considered a Roush anymore than a Ford Pinto with a snake on the grill is is a Cobra! LOL! I truly don't want to upset those owning "serial numbered cars" of any kind, but also let's not say a car built by a Roush authorized dealer under Roush specifications with a Roush warrantee is not a Roush! It just alienates people with by degrading nice cars! If you go to a Mustang Club meet or cruise night and go down the row of Mustangs saying "This is a Roush.... This is a Clone, Roush..... clone!" I suggest you leave your engine running on your number plated Roush! LOL! When you get to the stock Mustang with a Roush decal on it..... we all agree it is not a Roush! I doubt you agree, so let's just agree to disagree and enjoy our cars!

I'm done! Let's all get along, and appreciate any honestly describe cars!

Note: Beware of early Corvettes, because then can be built in any configuration and it cannot be discovered "IF" the builder knows his stuff! In the 70's a lot of high H.P. parts were taken off and replaced with easier to live with 4 Barrel carburetors!

Click the image to open in full size.

This is my one cylinder, number match diesel, with no electrical, water pump, fuel pump, etc. It is not a clone!

Peace be with you!
__________________
Maximum sig size is 250 px high X 500 px wide. Thank you.

Do you attack people who make posts you don't agree with? https://yourlogicalfallacyis.com/ad-hominem Abolish lazy terms: awesome, epic, amazing, extreme, sketchy, really?, "This bad boy", & "That's what I'm talking about!"(smile)

Last edited by Mr. D; 02-08-2014 at 06:49 AM.
Mr. D is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-08-2014, 09:02 AM   #40
LilRoush
6th Gear Member
 
LilRoush's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2007
Vehicle: Roush
Location: South FL
Posts: 8,528
Send a message via AIM to LilRoush
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Mr. D
....The point you and "Lil Roush" are missing, or ignoring, is that I never said that a car built by a authorized Roush dealer is the same, or worth the same as a Roush with a serial # plate! My point is that there should be a clear distinction made between a "clone" that is a fake having a couple of Roush decals and a Mustang with $10 to 20K modifications done by an authorized dealer, under Roush specfications, with a Roush warrantee. They can be done either for a Ford Dealership or an new owner. My original post tried to clarify that clear difference and was clear in stating that was not a factory made Roush, but it is still a Roush. The Ford dealer where I bought my Mustang had both Factory made, serial numbered Roush and Saleen cars and also Mustangs modified after they hit the dealership. Some were sent out to a local Roush authorized dealer and some were down by this authorized Roush Ford Dealership. They were modified under Roush specifications with a Roush guarantee related to the engine and drive train. I called Roush and they verified that such cars were considered Roush Mustangs simply constructed by an outside authorized source and were guaranteed by Roush. Obviously these Ford Dealers would be sued by Roush if they were doing something against their agreement with Roush. Ford also offered a "Ford extended warrantee" that covered the Roush modifications.

Now to be CLEAR, I am not saying that a car built by an authorized dealer is the same, or worth the same as a serial numbered factory made Roush.... but it should not be classed or valued in the same as a Mustang were Joe Blow adds a couple of decals in his garage and passes it off as a Roush! Those who own a serial numbered Roush car should not be so insecure about their car's evaluation as to need to devalue cars built by authorized Ford Dealers or independent authorized Roush dealers by saying they are not a Roush, but a clone!
Just wanted to touch a couple points. It's the term REAL that is still the issue. Calling it a Roush means it is a real Roush car built by Roush with a serial number.

In a previous post where you listed the 3 types of Roushs, as well as the underlined section here, you claim that a REAL Roush can be built at a dealer with misc Roush parts. My point is this is not true anymore. It is still a Mustang with Roush parts. A clone is a clone is a clone. IT IS NOT A REAL ROUSH WITHOUT THE SERIAL NUMBER.

I highly doubt anyone authorized to make that claim from Roush told you that they are 'real' when an authorized dealer installed the parts. Clearly anyone tied to Roush is happy to sell parts and spread the level of performance from the company. They make great stuff.

I'm not insecure at all about my cars, nor am I belittling anyone else's. I didn't say my cars are better or anything along those lines. I specifically stating what a REAL Roush is vs a dealer build/clone. I'm not alienating anyone with a clone. But if you want to say your car is a Roush, go get a Roush.

I think what is happening is you feel I'm belittling your car. I'm not. It's a nice car. I like it. But it's not a Roush. It's a GT with a Roush blower and graphic on the window.

I'm not the only one who has explained the difference between a Roush, a dealer build/clone and a car with Roush parts added before.

http://mustangforums.com/forum/salee...sh-clones.html

http://mustangforums.com/forum/salee...ns-rousch.html
__________________
~Matt
1998 Roush: M112'd Aluminum block 4.6L 2V 6 speed track car
1999 SVT: Mostly stockish
1970 Mach 1: Resto-modded monster

2000 Roush #5004 - World's FIRST M112'd V6 Mustang. Sold, but not forgotten.

Last edited by LilRoush; 02-08-2014 at 09:11 AM.
LilRoush is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-08-2014, 09:02 AM
MustangForums
Ford Mustang




Paid Advertisement

 
 
 
Reply

Tags
427r, buyer beware, clone, replica, roush

Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are Off
Pingbacks are Off
Refbacks are Off

Forum Jump

Advertising

Featured Sponsors
Vendor Directory
New Sponsors
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 02:04 PM.

© Internet Brands, Inc.


This forum is owned and operated by Internet Brands, Inc., a Delaware corporation. It is not authorized or endorsed by the Ford Motor Company and is not affiliated with the Ford Motor Company or its related companies in any way. Ford® is a registered trademark of the Ford Motor Company
Emails Backup