Off the wall question....Gated shifter?
#1
Off the wall question....Gated shifter?
I was just looking around at MGW shifters, etc. And my mind started wandering....you know how Ferrari's and what not have those aluminum/metal gated shifters? I wonder what it would look like on the S197s?
It's probably impossible to do anyways, b/c I've never seen one or heard of anyone doing this; and the way the the tranny works/positioned ....Sorry, if this is a really stupid question, ....but has anyone heard of anyone doing this? Just wondering....Thanks guys
Cheers,
It's probably impossible to do anyways, b/c I've never seen one or heard of anyone doing this; and the way the the tranny works/positioned ....Sorry, if this is a really stupid question, ....but has anyone heard of anyone doing this? Just wondering....Thanks guys
Cheers,
#2
Welcome to the forum and though no question is a stupid question in my book others on the forum may not think along the same lines as myself. If anyone gives you crap for this question and you feel you need me to step in or remove the thread just PM me and it will be handled!...... Now to answer your question I doubt it would happen on the stang and is actually a nice idea but were comparing apples to oranges here and everything needs to be cost effective when a car is being built at a factory (other then high end cars from Italy and other European countries etc) Aftermarket companies have not gone in that direction either from what I have seen and doubt it is cost effective for the many smaller aftermarket companies out there...... JMO
#3
Thanks for the welcome and input GT500, I appreciate it. So, it is not really that it can't be done; its more of a: MGW vs. Tri-ax vs. Pro 5.0 etc...and not really having a market for a gated shifter? Sorry that was confusing...So Ford obviously is not going to do it b/c($$$) and the aftermarket shifter companies won't do it because of $$$ and demand/performance/whatever....which is understandable...
I thought that the mustang 5-speed could never physically work with a gated shifter; for whatever reasons...like the way the stang shifts; would make a gated shifter impossible, etc. But I guess it would be the guys supplying the shifters that would make this happen; even if it was possible.
Thanks man, that answers my questions perfectly
btw...BAD*** Mustang!! Sooo clean!
I thought that the mustang 5-speed could never physically work with a gated shifter; for whatever reasons...like the way the stang shifts; would make a gated shifter impossible, etc. But I guess it would be the guys supplying the shifters that would make this happen; even if it was possible.
Thanks man, that answers my questions perfectly
btw...BAD*** Mustang!! Sooo clean!
#4
thought that the mustang 5-speed could never physically work with a gated shifter; for whatever reasons...like the way the stang shifts; would make a gated shifter impossible, etc
Thanks for the compliment on the stang......and yes I am a perfectionist and it is extremely clean!
#5
I was actually thinking about the same thing...and i didnt think it would be that difficult. However I thought the gated shifter was just the metal gates instead of a shift boot.....but from what you guys are saying it seems like its something with the transmission/shifter?
#6
shouldnt be too hard to make one from some thin sheet alluminum, if you had good tools, and a couple hours, and some skillz! the one thing i would worry about would be horrible rattling noises from the shifter contacting the metal gate piece.
#8
gated shifters are just not found on American cars.
But they are really going out of style now, with most Ferraris and such switching to auto/shift or clutchless transmissions and paddle shifters.
I always liked the locked out first gear feature of the Lambo (and I think most all the others) but with computers running everything they have become obsolete!
But they are really going out of style now, with most Ferraris and such switching to auto/shift or clutchless transmissions and paddle shifters.
I always liked the locked out first gear feature of the Lambo (and I think most all the others) but with computers running everything they have become obsolete!
#9
A few design thoughts:
You still need a boot underneath it to keep fumes and anything that splashes up off the road from coming in.
It needs to not foul the shifter stub itself or a shift lever fastener, and either be able to fit over the lever from the top or permit lever replacement if the lever is first removed (avoiding shift **** removal).
Gate slots need to be wide enough to accommodate the thickness of the shift lever plus some allowance for the drivetrain torquing over (toward the passenger side) plus enough clearance to eliminate rattles. The remaining metal "fingers" between the slots need to be wide enough so that they won't bend easily.
You need to develop a reliable method of getting it locating such that you actually end up with the clearances that you sized the slots for.
Norm
You still need a boot underneath it to keep fumes and anything that splashes up off the road from coming in.
It needs to not foul the shifter stub itself or a shift lever fastener, and either be able to fit over the lever from the top or permit lever replacement if the lever is first removed (avoiding shift **** removal).
Gate slots need to be wide enough to accommodate the thickness of the shift lever plus some allowance for the drivetrain torquing over (toward the passenger side) plus enough clearance to eliminate rattles. The remaining metal "fingers" between the slots need to be wide enough so that they won't bend easily.
You need to develop a reliable method of getting it locating such that you actually end up with the clearances that you sized the slots for.
Norm
Last edited by Norm Peterson; 01-08-2009 at 09:17 AM.
#10
I've thought about this too, but I'm no fabricator so I have no means of making the plate or the shaft for the shifter.
I too really like the look of Ferrari's and Lamborghini's, the best I've been able to do is Hurst shifter with a polished shift ****. The know I have only cost like $20 off of eBay, but if you want something a little more high end here is a good ****...
http://www.twmshiftknobs.com/shiftkn...hiftknobs.html
I too really like the look of Ferrari's and Lamborghini's, the best I've been able to do is Hurst shifter with a polished shift ****. The know I have only cost like $20 off of eBay, but if you want something a little more high end here is a good ****...
http://www.twmshiftknobs.com/shiftkn...hiftknobs.html