Threw a Rod on the KB Tune
#21
I had assumed that the rods were observed to have failed under a compression load (as in a whole bunch of chamber presuure pushing the pistion as in comes up on the compression stroke); vs. a tension load (as in top of stroke w/ valves open).
As to the OP's situation, he has my condolences for his loss. However, pushing a stock 2V bottom end to 362/427@5k at the wheels (approx 410/482 at the crank), is playing near the edge.
When Ford decided to bulid a 4.6L 390HP engine ('03/'04 Cobra) they moved to forged internals and 4V heads--not just to spend more money but because they knew the limits of the 2V with its cast metal internals...
As to the OP's situation, he has my condolences for his loss. However, pushing a stock 2V bottom end to 362/427@5k at the wheels (approx 410/482 at the crank), is playing near the edge.
When Ford decided to bulid a 4.6L 390HP engine ('03/'04 Cobra) they moved to forged internals and 4V heads--not just to spend more money but because they knew the limits of the 2V with its cast metal internals...
#22
What spark plugs were you running?
This seems far too conveinant and simple to just write it off as "too much pressure." What makes Eric so confident its the "pressure" that caused this? How can KB do thousands of pulls on a stock motor and never throw two rods like that? Even people that take the risk to go up to 11 PSI on the stock motor either never have issues or at least get a few months out of it before it blows. You did it on your first dyno pull when it was "rich." I'm no tuner or engineering but i'll be frank this has nothing to do with "too much pressure"....absolutely nothing indicates that. Why did it happen to blow on the dyno? Youve probably done plenty of spirited driving without issues, I assume you didnt bring a knocking or pinging engine to be dyno tuned.
I would definitely call KB, talk to them and see if they will look at your data log file and see what their opinion is. According to them your engine will never ever ever fail simply due to the pressure of the SC and they have the testing to back that up. They break alllll of this down in the documentation they send you.
This seems far too conveinant and simple to just write it off as "too much pressure." What makes Eric so confident its the "pressure" that caused this? How can KB do thousands of pulls on a stock motor and never throw two rods like that? Even people that take the risk to go up to 11 PSI on the stock motor either never have issues or at least get a few months out of it before it blows. You did it on your first dyno pull when it was "rich." I'm no tuner or engineering but i'll be frank this has nothing to do with "too much pressure"....absolutely nothing indicates that. Why did it happen to blow on the dyno? Youve probably done plenty of spirited driving without issues, I assume you didnt bring a knocking or pinging engine to be dyno tuned.
I would definitely call KB, talk to them and see if they will look at your data log file and see what their opinion is. According to them your engine will never ever ever fail simply due to the pressure of the SC and they have the testing to back that up. They break alllll of this down in the documentation they send you.
I definitely ran the car hard before through 3rd gear.. I managed to dish it out to a few vettes along the way. It seems like it was just the time that it gave out. A buddy of mine posted my story on svtp, and Mike from KB claimed if it was the tunes fault, it was because of longtubes and I shouldn't have trusted the longtubes or some bs like that. I like KB a lot, and I don't think it was the tune itself, but I thought that excuse was kinda lame.
There were a lot of people on hand that day, quite a few with notable experience, and it really was the consensous that the engine just quit on me.
It's definitely depressing, considering it'll take at least the better part of the summer for me to upgrade and install, but if there was any way this thing was gonna go out, it definitely picked the best place and time. Eric was really nice about, the no one charged me and one of the guys there even used his AAA to get me a free tow.
#25
That being said can the OP post a data log at the time this happened? I also believe that Eric uses an AFM1000 or a Lambda Pro at his place so I would trust the data.
#27
What spark plugs were you running?
This seems far too conveinant and simple to just write it off as "too much pressure." What makes Eric so confident its the "pressure" that caused this? How can KB do thousands of pulls on a stock motor and never throw two rods like that? Even people that take the risk to go up to 11 PSI on the stock motor either never have issues or at least get a few months out of it before it blows. You did it on your first dyno pull when it was "rich." I'm no tuner or engineering but i'll be frank this has nothing to do with "too much pressure"....absolutely nothing indicates that. Why did it happen to blow on the dyno? Youve probably done plenty of spirited driving without issues, I assume you didnt bring a knocking or pinging engine to be dyno tuned.
I would definitely call KB, talk to them and see if they will look at your data log file and see what their opinion is. According to them your engine will never ever ever fail simply due to the pressure of the SC and they have the testing to back that up. They break alllll of this down in the documentation they send you.
This seems far too conveinant and simple to just write it off as "too much pressure." What makes Eric so confident its the "pressure" that caused this? How can KB do thousands of pulls on a stock motor and never throw two rods like that? Even people that take the risk to go up to 11 PSI on the stock motor either never have issues or at least get a few months out of it before it blows. You did it on your first dyno pull when it was "rich." I'm no tuner or engineering but i'll be frank this has nothing to do with "too much pressure"....absolutely nothing indicates that. Why did it happen to blow on the dyno? Youve probably done plenty of spirited driving without issues, I assume you didnt bring a knocking or pinging engine to be dyno tuned.
I would definitely call KB, talk to them and see if they will look at your data log file and see what their opinion is. According to them your engine will never ever ever fail simply due to the pressure of the SC and they have the testing to back that up. They break alllll of this down in the documentation they send you.
#28
Hey man please give us full details on the specs of your car right UP to the event... I am literally about a week away from throwing my blower on my GT. This kinda has put a "halt" in my plans (a little bit at least). How many miles were on ur engine? How much boost were you pushing before it blew? Please give us all the juicy tech specs. Thanks man.
BTW, sorry for your loss. Hopefully this will work out better in the long run when you decide to throw in a MMR block and call it a day
BTW, sorry for your loss. Hopefully this will work out better in the long run when you decide to throw in a MMR block and call it a day
#29
Stevecooper - I understand 100% the difference between intake manifold pressure and cylinder pressure and what he was trying to say. When I say "pressure" I am referring to cylinder pressure. Have you ever heard of Inertia Loading and how it is affected by forced induction? The cylinder pressure caused by this supercharger did not blow this engine.
Thunderhorse i'm in the same exact boat here. I ****ing love KB and trust them A LOT but I think that was a lame *** excuse too. I would really push this issue and get somebody from KB on the phone. The way they swear up and down about their tunes I would personally never expect my car to be showering coolant and oil down on the dyno. If they stand by their tunes that much(and they do if you read their documentation) then they need to stand by them and buy you a brand new shortblock. If its the longtubes fault they never should have agreed to tune your car. Thats fault on their end IMO.
This being said I still <3 KB :P
Thunderhorse i'm in the same exact boat here. I ****ing love KB and trust them A LOT but I think that was a lame *** excuse too. I would really push this issue and get somebody from KB on the phone. The way they swear up and down about their tunes I would personally never expect my car to be showering coolant and oil down on the dyno. If they stand by their tunes that much(and they do if you read their documentation) then they need to stand by them and buy you a brand new shortblock. If its the longtubes fault they never should have agreed to tune your car. Thats fault on their end IMO.
This being said I still <3 KB :P
#30
I wouldn't be so quick to blame this on the tune. Bad tunes cause detonation which causes piston damage most often......rods break under too much power/stress or if they already have been compromised by a hairline fracture or something else. I highly doubt the KB tune was bad enough to smoke your rods on the first dyno pull. Did you or anyone else hear any detonation during this pull? I don't hear anything in the vid, although it can be hard to hear sometimes. It would be interesting to see the datalog.
Chances are your engine was gonna go once it was making a certain amount of power under a hard enough load no matter what tune the car was running.
Chances are your engine was gonna go once it was making a certain amount of power under a hard enough load no matter what tune the car was running.