Thanks for all the input. I prefer the clean look of the stock one, but a new one from the dealer is very pricey plus it would have to be painted. The dent is an inward dent but it has also slightly wrinkled and flaked off the paint on an outer edge spot, so a dent removal guy would probably have a hard time with it.

PROMETHEUS, I'm located in the Mid-Hudson area of New York (New Paltz zip 12561).