Ok, well, sorry, but you all might be wrong. The seal on my door got messed up, and now I have a slight water leak issue. The seal isn't sitting right now and when the door moves at all it squeaks. It can't be the shocks or anything because I pushed down hard on the front of my car to compress it, and no squeak, but when I gently opened my door it squeaked.

 

So your door has been squeaking this whole time and you didn't realize that.

 

Well from sitting inside my car, no, I did not. I just knew it was coming from some area forward and to the left. Funny thing is though, it never happened before I took it to tuffy, and same with the slight water leak.

Still don't know how to fix it though.

 

Ok, well I was wrong again. I just remembered that when I would open or close the door it would squeak about halfway open/closed, and at that point the 2 rubber pieces are not touching. Gah

 

New theory: It's the mirror.

If I can't figure out how to fix it soon I might just have to order a pair of those agent 47 mirrors!

 

I fixed it, thanks everyone for the help!

I just popped the mirror out and tightened up the screws, 2 were loose.