Between the two body styles I like the 05-09 better. I don't hate the 10-12s I just don't like those awful tail lights.

 

In their stock form (as pictured) I would say the 05-09 all day long. I have never been a fan of the new body style tails UNTIL I got a look at one with the saleen rear body kit installed...Pure heaven I tell ya!
Fills out the rear as it should have been to begin with and a must for the 2010+ imo.

 

05-09 for sure.
Now the fronts are a different story. I think I like the 10+ front more.

 

Kinda apples to oranges IMO (stock rear vs modded) but 99% of the time it's the 05-09s for me

 

Both look good my man.. Really hard to choose!

 

I'm slowly getting use to the 2010+ rear end, however I prefer the looks of the 2005-2009. I will say 2013 is much improved over the 2010-2012 IMO.

 

05-09.

I fell in love with the S197 when it came out because of the retro look to the original styling. The '10 lost some of that.

 

Even though I like the 2010 tail lights better I have to say the 06. I think the 2010 is bubble like. Too importy. I am definitely getting the 2010 style taillights though. they look great

 

Thanks Soldier GT!

 

I am kind of half & half. Part of me likes the 10 and part of me likes the 06.
I am kinda surprised no one has mentioned my fox body in the background.