Those tires look better. They don't look weird at all.

 

Keep them. Much better IMO.

 

I think it's perfect, 19s look at home on your car and the 255/45 tires also look great.

I have a buddy that has 30mm sidewall and IMO it hurts the ride a lot (especially when you hit those potholes), plus the proportions look a little off with his 18s.

 

Your over thinking IMO. They look great.

 

Damn your car looks fantastic. The wheels look great, too.

 

I like the wheels and gap looks great! I'd keep em.

 

I think they look great.

 

Car looks amazing. Dont change anything.

 

The gap looks fine to me. On the color, you could always plastidip them before committing to something more permanent than paint. We made a mad dash from Denver to Vegas one day to buy a set of these same wheels and yesterday, I clipped a curb. Fortunately it just scuffed the side wall of the tire and not the wheel so Im glad my wife didnt kill me.

 

Those wheels look great! I'd keep them the same color IMO.