Toe alignment shouldn't be affected by wheel width or offset. The hub is going to put the wheel where it's supposed to no matter the size width or offset.

 

i am not familiar with spiggot rings.. can anyone enlighten me? what size would i need?

 

Another solution that can be overlooked is that the tires may be cupped...
Doesn't happen often, but it is another possibility!

It happened to me once before. Luckily in my case, great customer service prevailed and they replaced the tires for me after verifying that was the case.

 

You said you got new wheels, but did you reuse the tires? because the tires could be out of round.

 

brand new tires.. any input on the spiggot rings?

 

Some tires come bad from the factory, so don't discard that. As for the hub centric rings, they are just adapter rings you put on the rim to adjust the center bore size to the car's hub. usually made out of plastic or aluminum. This video explains it pretty well:

 

^^^^^^
Hub centric rings could be the solution if the center bores are larger. I have seen customer cars with aftermarket wheels have the same issue. Got them the correct hub centric rings and voila, problem fixed. Although, pretty rare for 5 lug cars. 4 lug cars usually have more of an issue.