I am working on replacing all the broken stuff on my 96. I picked up a new center console out of a 99 vert. Looked good at the junk yard, but when I cleaned it up and installed it, I noticed that it is not really as black as the rest of my plastic pieces. More on the gray side. Armor-all did help some but not as much as I would have liked. Anything you guys could recommend? I looked at the Back to Black but I dont know if it would be OK for interior pieces.

 

How about black rattle can spray paint?

A test could be tried on the old part that is being replaced for color and for compatibility.