I sold my 17" silver bullits on craigslist for $500. About 30K miles. One tire definitely needed to be replaced.

 

I sold my 12' brembo 1500 mile take offs for 1100 - 500$ for the tires, 600$ for the wheels.

not helpful to your scenario, but I imagine someone may search for this info in the future. doesn't hurt to have a thread full of what various oem wheels and tires are worth.

 

Just sold my stock 17's for $500, to give you more reference.

 

I just sold my stock wheels with new tires on them for $600 on CL with center caps.

 

Sold my 4 18" Polished Bullits with tires 235/50/18 (90% tread)
for $650