I had just purchased BM Titanium when everyone started praising ICE; so I bought it too. I haven't fully waxed a vehicle yet but did a quick comparison.


I just used the hatch of my '04 durango for time sake. As far as prep, I just washed it real quick and wiped it dry, that is it. No wax seems to last long on the rear hatch so its always on the worst shape.

ICE by far is the easiest to (ever) and I even did the wiper arm with it. It however doesn't remove ANYTHING from the paint, not even the smallest chamois water spots. The paint feels slightly oily after but very slick.


You can see the small water spots:






The Black Magic Titanium is also very easy to apply/remove, just a little harder than ICE. The finish feels dry and silky and it removed the water spots. I didnt get it on the trim so I dont know what happens.





Right ICE, Left BM Titanium. I'm curious to see which lasts the longest. ICE is so easy to use, it may not matter. I also wonder if ICE really is "wet" and if dust will want to stick to it.