i have 3 different brands which one do you recommend: ice tire shine, black magic titanium tire gel, or armor all extreme tire shine.

 

I have never tried any of those products but got hooked up w/ Zaino Perfect Tire Gloss (rubber & trim) Protectant from someone here at the forums and I just love it. It is not greasy nor does it sling off. Not sure you really want to add a forth product, just my 2 cents.

 

Unless you want to have a brownish black tar buildup that will not wash off stay away from Armor All Extreme!!!

 

I have great experience with Optimum tire shine, no slinging whatsoever and gives a nice matte look, not really that shiny but thats what i prefer. Protects the tire pretty well, my car is parked outside all day and with the sun on my tires, it never turns yellow.

 

I have tried a few, and so far Black Magic Titanium spray has been my favorite. Nice and shiney(my Preference). And no sling.

 

Try perfect tire gloss by Zaino! great stuff!