oil question
#21
From my understanding higher oil temps and the beating the oil takes going through the blower, will cause it to shear down. Not a big issue but I would step up a grade or two.
#22
This is why I stay out of oil discussions--I will make one comment however...
Full synthetic motor oils are without doubt superior to dino, and non-"true synthetic", oils--however that level of superiority is irrelevant as it is not needed to properly lubricate an automobile engine, IF the lubricant is kept clean and undamaged (overheating. contaminated, etc.).
Over the years I have run numerous vehicles to well over 250k miles on dino oil changed every 2500 to 3000 miles. I run synthetic (Pennzoil Ultra) in my GT, also changed at 2.5 to 3k, but mostly because I can get it and a Motorcraft filter for $25 or so at Walmart.
Full synthetic motor oils are without doubt superior to dino, and non-"true synthetic", oils--however that level of superiority is irrelevant as it is not needed to properly lubricate an automobile engine, IF the lubricant is kept clean and undamaged (overheating. contaminated, etc.).
Over the years I have run numerous vehicles to well over 250k miles on dino oil changed every 2500 to 3000 miles. I run synthetic (Pennzoil Ultra) in my GT, also changed at 2.5 to 3k, but mostly because I can get it and a Motorcraft filter for $25 or so at Walmart.
#24
Sure, your engine made the 250K miles with ease on dino oils, but let's tear it apart and compare it to the internals of an engine ran 250K miles on a true group IV synthetic lubricant.
There will be no comparison.
Increased oil weight, and MPG improved, Possible?
Last edited by Unleashedbeast; 11-17-2010 at 02:37 PM.
#26
When I am saying shelf brand full synthetic I am referring to group III base forumlas that are labeled as "full synthetic", such as synpower,pennzoil ultra, mobil one, so on and so fourth. Im not trying to debate group IV oils and by no means am i saying UOAs are false, I am just simply stating its a pet peve of mine to change my oil every 3 months regardless, I'm rather particular about fluid changes and I'm so **** about it I cut my oil filter open each time and inspect for any foreign material................For the 30-35$ every 3 months it might be realistically a waste of money but it gives me peice of mind especially if I find evidence of future engine failure inside that filter. Also on a comedic note it gives me an excuse to get a case of beer and some buddies down the garage and get away from the woman for a few hours and thats PRICELESS.
As far as that debate I personally do not see any benefit running the group IV over the group III considering I change it on a 3 month base regardless of mileage.
As far as that debate I personally do not see any benefit running the group IV over the group III considering I change it on a 3 month base regardless of mileage.
all im saying is personally, i would much rather use oil that has PROVEN protection than buy some shelf brand and have to cut the filter open every 3 months with some sort of small expectation that things are going bad. i'm no rocket scientist but if you really trusted the oil you were putting in your car, you wouldnt be doing that. i cant say ive ever cut open a single oil filter looking for "stuff".
since you never mentioned or i just cant remember, what oil do you use?
why 2.5k miles on pennzoil ultra? i was running amsoil till my last oil change (unexpected trip came up) and i bought some pennzoil ultra at walmart my first night gone. literally knew nothing about it until i googled it on my phone, i cant even tell you what the true group of the oil is at this point i read so much sketchy information about it because pennzoil wont even release the full details, but best i can tell its a 40-50% group iv/iii blend depending on which weight you buy. all UOA's i saw were from 7k mile OCI's and returned perfect results, and were even reccomended to run longer drain intervals. amsoil is going back in when i pop 7000 miles on this stuff just because i am more familiar with it.
pennzoil guarantees ultra on their 500k mile warranty to protect however much the manufacturer reccomends for an OCI (which some cars is 7500 miles, some its 3000 miles). they even said if your OEM specs were to change oil at 12-15k miles, they will honor their warranty if the oil was changed at that frequency.
Last edited by MU71L4710N; 11-18-2010 at 05:11 AM.
#27
well...thats your god given right. if your eyeball scanning of a cut open oil filter is as good a judgement of oil quality to you as a chemical analysis, then keep doing what your doing.
all im saying is personally, i would much rather use oil that has PROVEN protection than buy some shelf brand and have to cut the filter open every 3 months with some sort of small expectation that things are going bad. i'm no rocket scientist but if you really trusted the oil you were putting in your car, you wouldnt be doing that. i cant say ive ever cut open a single oil filter looking for "stuff".
since you never mentioned or i just cant remember, what oil do you use?
all im saying is personally, i would much rather use oil that has PROVEN protection than buy some shelf brand and have to cut the filter open every 3 months with some sort of small expectation that things are going bad. i'm no rocket scientist but if you really trusted the oil you were putting in your car, you wouldnt be doing that. i cant say ive ever cut open a single oil filter looking for "stuff".
since you never mentioned or i just cant remember, what oil do you use?
Last edited by uberstang1; 11-18-2010 at 05:23 AM.
#28
Sure, your engine made the 250K miles with ease on dino oils, but let's tear it apart and compare it to the internals of an engine ran 250K miles on a true group IV synthetic lubricant.
#29
literally knew nothing about it until i googled it on my phone, i cant even tell you what the true group of the oil is at this point i read so much sketchy information about it because pennzoil wont even release the full details, but best i can tell its a 40-50% group iv/iii blend depending on which weight you buy.
The below quote is taken directly from BITOG forums from their "ask Pennzoil" section.
Ask Pennzoil
11. Are the base stocks group III, IV, or V?
Pennzoil Ultra™ is blended with Group III base stocks. These give superior solvency performance to Group IV base stocks, which we believe aids our aim to provide oil that delivers as close to “Factory Clean”. Rather than focus on any single component in the formulation, we focus on the end product.
Pennzoil Ultra™ is blended with Group III base stocks. These give superior solvency performance to Group IV base stocks, which we believe aids our aim to provide oil that delivers as close to “Factory Clean”. Rather than focus on any single component in the formulation, we focus on the end product.
Before I even finish this post I just want to state im not trying to bash group IV oils in any way shape or form I understand they are a better oil. But my question is if you have two motors that made it to 250k miles and failed, and one had group IV and one had a "fake" synthetic and you tore the motors down and the group IV looked cleaner and what not what really is the point if they both only made it to 250k?
While your dino oil engine @ 250K miles is needing a refresh, the group IV PAO engine @ 250K miles will still have plenty of life left in it. I've seen this before, and will continue to see it again.
Last edited by Unleashedbeast; 11-18-2010 at 08:05 PM.
#30
U
The point is, and not assuming broke down engines, I'm talking about engines that are still running.
While your dino oil engine @ 250K miles is needing a refresh, the group IV PAO engine @ 250K miles will still have plenty of life left in it. I've seen this before, and will continue to see it again.
The point is, and not assuming broke down engines, I'm talking about engines that are still running.
While your dino oil engine @ 250K miles is needing a refresh, the group IV PAO engine @ 250K miles will still have plenty of life left in it. I've seen this before, and will continue to see it again.
less frequent maint.
better fuel economy,
heck in my brothers focus he gained 2mpg, That alone makes it worth it for him.